Tribunal to investigate gross misconduct allegations made against both Hlophe and Goliath

Western Cape High Court Judge John Hlophe and Deputy Judge President Patricia Goliath could now both face gross misconduct probe.

This decision comes after the Judicial Conduct Appeals Committee recommended on Tuesday that a tribunal be established to investigate allegations against both of them.

The tribunal will investigate Hlophe’s allegations against his deputy Patricia Goliath which include racism.

The tribunal will also investigate allegations by Goliath against Hlophe of assault, abusive language and abuse of power in relation to the office of the deputy judge president.

Hlophe had lodged an appeal after former Chief Justice Mogoeng Mogoeng recommended in 2020 to the Judicial Service Commission’s conduct committee that it advise the commission to establish a tribunal to probe the claims against Hlophe.

Goliath had initially lodged a complaint of gross misconduct against Hlophe and his wife, Judge Gayaat Salie-Hlope.

“The framing of this complaint in this manner may not be ideal to the extent that some of the alleged acts of misconduct asserted therein could well constitute self-standing complaints, as adverted to by the Chief Justice in his decision and The JP in his submissions on appeal,” the ruling said.

Mogoeng had recommended that a tribunal investigate three of Goliath’s claims against Hlophe.One of the complaints was that Hlophe allegedly assaulted a Judge in his division.

Mogoeng also dismissed Hlophe’s counter-complaints against Goliath saying none had merit.

On Tuesday, the appeals committee dismissed Hlophe’s appeal against Mogoeng’s decision that a tribunal be established to investigate and report on complaints by Goliath.

However, the committee said it differed with Mogoeng on some aspects.

One related to utterances allegedly made by Goliath to Hlophe’s wife.

“I do not think the issue can be resolved on paper. Particularly at this stage of the proceedings,” judge Nambitha Dambuza said in her ruling.

“If the allegations of racism against Goliath were established, including the allegation that the deputy judge president referred to some judges as ‘kaxxxxies’ or that the judge president and judge Salie Hlophe lied in imputing the allegations to [Goliath] gross misconduct could be proved either way.”

Source: News24, Times Live, SABC News, image from Times Live: Trevor Samson

Doctor Mahlaule

Doctor Mahlaule previously worked as a Freelance Journalist at Find-it SA where he was responsible for writing news articles and sharing them on social media platforms. Doctor Mahlaule holds a Diploma in Journalism, BA in Communication Science and a BA Honours in Media Studies. Doctor began his journey as a knowledge Management and Communications Intern at Zenex Foundation. He was responsible for support in event management, social media, website maintenance, writing and brand management. On weekends Doctor attends prison ministry and shares the scriptures with inmates at Krugersdorp prison and plays soccer in the afternoon on some weekends. He has a passion for reading and writing and enjoys going out with friends and socialising in his spare time. He has a one-year-old son and is planning on getting married soon. When asked about what keeps him going, he said: “My family keeps me going. I’m the man I am because I come from a loving home. I have a very supportive family who always encourages me to keep pushing hard.”

See Full Bio